SPECIAL NOTICE: INFER is now the RAND Forecasting Initiative (RFI). Learn more about RFI.
 
11th
Accuracy Rank

johnnycaffeine

About:
Show more

0.134422

Relative Brier Score

62

Forecasts

6

Upvotes
Forecasting Activity
Forecasting Calendar
 

Past Week Past Month Past Year This Season All Time
Forecasts 13 26 402 216 1138
Comments 10 10 53 38 275
Questions Forecasted 8 18 69 40 168
Upvotes on Comments By This User 15 16 144 79 467
 Definitions
New Prediction
johnnycaffeine
made their 11th forecast (view all):
Probability
Answer
Forecast Window
90% (+20%)
Yes
Sep 30, 2024 to Mar 30, 2025
10% (-20%)
No
Sep 30, 2024 to Mar 30, 2025

Washington Post: Israel tells Washington it plans imminent ground operation in Lebanon, U.S. official says

Israel is planning a limited ground operation in Lebanon that could start imminently, Israel has told Washington, a U.S. official said. Israel’s planned campaign would be smaller than its last war against Hezbollah in 2006 and would focus on clearing out militant infrastructure along the border to remove the threat to Israeli border communities, the official said, speaking on the condition of anonymity to discuss private talks between the two governments. On Monday, Israeli forces carried out limited raids in Lebanon, according to an Israeli familiar with the operation, who spoke on the condition of anonymity to discuss a sensitive matter.
Files
LogicCurve
made a comment:
I agree with your statement.  The entire crowd is at one side of the question.  As you see I am not following the crowd, but for good reason.   
Files
New Prediction
johnnycaffeine
made their 10th forecast (view all):
Probability
Answer
Forecast Window
70% (+22%)
Yes
Sep 30, 2024 to Mar 30, 2025
30% (-22%)
No
Sep 30, 2024 to Mar 30, 2025
Show more
Why might you be wrong?

There's a scramble of last-minute diplomacy, especially from the United States, which does not want to see the conflict escalated, since the US is so tied in with Israel. 

Files
LogicCurve
made a comment:
Yes, that is true.  I'm wondering what source you have that may hint that Israel might authorize these steps.   They did announce these in the beginning of the war.  
Files
New Prediction
johnnycaffeine
made their 16th forecast (view all):
Probability
Answer
1% (0%)
Kuwait
1% (-1%)
Oman
1% (0%)
Qatar
1% (-3%)
Saudi Arabia
1% (0%)
Tunisia

These are all close to zero in this timeframe.

Files
New Prediction
johnnycaffeine
made their 9th forecast (view all):
Probability
Answer
Forecast Window
48% (+8%)
Yes
Sep 29, 2024 to Mar 29, 2025
52% (-8%)
No
Sep 29, 2024 to Mar 29, 2025

Going up a little along with the Crowd. Often in forecasting, it's important to realize one's personal limitations and understand the wisdom of one's fellow forecasters.

At the moment, however, I'm maintaining under 50%. The Israeli invasion of Lebanon in 2006 caused a lot of headaches, and then not to mention the 2-decade occupation of Lebanon before that.  The IDF has just eased restrictions on residents of northern Israel; this is not something I would imagine they would do if a declaration of war/ground invasion were imminent. Also, it's important to note that Israel has been struggling with its image in the international community. This is something that may limit Israel's abilities to declare war with Hezbollah in the absence of a clear casus belli.

Files
LogicCurve
made a comment:

@johnnycaffeine , good info. The fact that the Israeli Home Front Command lifted restrictions in some northern Israel cities is significant. They have continued to strike "120 Hezbollah Targets" on Sunday (today), and caused "significant damage."

https://www.jpost.com/breaking-news/article-822397

Files
New Prediction
Why do you think you're right?

I have not seen anything yet that would cause me to want to go above the base rate. Djibouti was an easy win for China, and I'm just not sure another one is doable for them quite yet. The US recently used its softpower to deny China a base in Gabon:

The US move comes after what American officials say were Chinese attempts to establish a military training facility in the Atlantic coast nation, which US officials believe could serve as a precursor to a permanent base. The US maintains a sprawling network of military installations around the world — including in China’s backyard — but views any Chinese base on the Atlantic as a red line.
The package, which isn’t finalized, will be unveiled during a visit to the US by Gabonese interim President Brice Clotaire Oligui Nguema in late September or early October, the people said. It will also include radar to help the country monitor illegal fishing, an expansion of its partnership with the West Virginia National Guard, and assistance with conservation in its national parks.



Files
Why might you be wrong?

Tanzania and Mozambique are the next areas where China will make its attempt, according to Bloomberg: 

While a Chinese military presence on Africa’s eastern seaboard would likely be less worrying for the US than Atlantic access, it would enhance China’s ability to project power into the Indian Ocean, as well as in the Middle East. The waters around southern and eastern Africa have also become more strategically significant as Houthi militant attacks on shipping in the Red Sea force many commercial vessels to sail around the southern tip of Africa.
China conducted trilateral military drills with the two countries last month.

However:

Tanzanian Defence Minister Stergomena Tax and Mozambican Transportation and Communications Minister Mateus Magala both said via text message that they’re unaware of any plans to build bases or station Chinese troops in their respective countries.


Files
New Prediction
johnnycaffeine
made their 8th forecast (view all):
Probability
Answer
Forecast Window
40% (-30%)
Yes
Sep 28, 2024 to Mar 28, 2025
60% (+30%)
No
Sep 28, 2024 to Mar 28, 2025
Why do you think you're right?

The Israelis are well aware that their ground incursion in Lebanon in 2006 was very difficult. Good history of it here, btw. That subject had to have come up many times in the war cabinet proceedings, that they don't want history to repeat. They don't want to fight Hezbollah in what one might call a "fair fight," where Hezbollah's fighters can do all sorts of ambushes and draw the IDF ground troops into various traps they've prepared. Plus the Israelis have had enough trouble in Gaza as it is.

And so, what has happened instead is they've used the Mossad and Israeli Air Force to wipe out much of Hezbollah in a low-risk manner.  This tweet from Israel says it all.

So at this point, I would find it surprising if we saw a war declaration (or equivalent) like they did with Hamas. There is a method of forecasting where you go with weighing what outcomes would make you more surprised, so I'll go with that. 

Files
Why might you be wrong?

On the other hand, there are stories such as this from the Washington Post: Israeli troops on Lebanon border say they’re ready for ground invasion

So the option of a declaration of war and going in would also not be too surprising. 

Files
LogicCurve
made a comment:
Yes, @johnnycaffeinethat tweet does say a lot! 
Files
New Prediction
johnnycaffeine
made their 7th forecast (view all):
Probability
Answer
Forecast Window
70% (+5%)
Yes
Sep 28, 2024 to Mar 28, 2025
30% (-5%)
No
Sep 28, 2024 to Mar 28, 2025

Moving this up to be closer to the Crowd, but to me it seems like Israel is taking out Hezbollah without a declaration of war, etc.

Files
johnnycaffeine
made a comment:
Yeah, you're right I'll move it back down. 
Files
New Prediction
Confirmed previous forecast
Files
New Prediction
johnnycaffeine
made their 11th forecast (view all):
Probability
Answer
Forecast Window
1% (0%)
Yes
Sep 27, 2024 to Mar 27, 2025
99% (0%)
No
Sep 27, 2024 to Mar 27, 2025
Confirmed previous forecast
Files
New Prediction
johnnycaffeine
made their 1st forecast (view all):
Probability
Answer
Forecast Window
40%
Yes
Sep 26, 2024 to Mar 26, 2025
60%
No
Sep 26, 2024 to Mar 26, 2025

A lot of great points from the other forecasters, such as @DKC mentioning Cameroon, here

 A long-term base rate visualization is at VOA News. I haven't crunched the numbers, but from looking it, maybe 30%-35% of 6-month periods since the turn of the 21st century have had successful coups. 

Good article here from WarOnTheRocks discussing various factors involved, which may boost that base rate, for example:

Moreover, the recent withdrawal of French and European troops, who had been at the forefront of counter-terrorism efforts in the region, coincides with the emergence of private military companies. These companies, operating with less transparency and accountability, may exacerbate the existing security vacuum. Simultaneously, the “reckless exploitation of natural resources” by external actors and corrupt local leaders threatens the region’s stability. This volatile combination is likely to foster increased instability, potentially leading to more coup attempts. Furthermore, such circumstances could inadvertently strengthen populist support for regimes that emerge in the aftermath of these coups.

There are also a ton of uncertainties (since it's not like we know what plots are underway). Also, it's notable that the resolution criteria require a successful coup.  This is a strong argument for going with the long-term base rate; however, I want to nudge it upward due to factors such as the recent withdrawal of French and European troops.


Files
johnnycaffeine
made a comment:
Thanks!
Files
Files
Tip: Mention someone by typing @username