SPECIAL NOTICE: INFER is now the RAND Forecasting Initiative (RFI). Learn more about RFI.
 
7th
Accuracy Rank

probahilliby

About:
Show more

No Scores Yet

Relative Brier Score

0

Forecasts

0

Upvotes
Forecasting Activity
Forecasting Calendar
 

Past Week Past Month Past Year This Season All Time
Forecasts 0 0 419 134 1090
Comments 0 0 13 7 73
Questions Forecasted 0 0 82 43 101
Upvotes on Comments By This User 0 0 24 9 104
 Definitions
New Badge
probahilliby
earned a new badge:

Oracle - Bronze

Earned for being in the Top 10% of the leaderboard 3 months in a row.
New Badge
probahilliby
earned a new badge:

Top Forecaster - Aug 2024

Earned for being in the Top 10% of the leaderboard in a month.
New Prediction

I started off with the assumption that Djibouti would have about a 60% probability of being the immediate choice of a Chinese base in Africa based on all inferences and incentives that would benefit both countries. I then distributed the remaining 40% across the next 5 years or so, and the resulting probability of this IFP resolving YES in the next two years was something like 12.5%. I'm rounding down because I'm probably overestimating here.


Food for thought: would increased activity with the Philippines cause us to increase or decrease the odds here? On one hand, it would seem aggression and expansion by China is increasing. On the other hand, more activity in the South China Sea could pull away Chinese resources in Africa, slowing progress. Assessing the tradeoffs between China's desire based on regional conflicts remains a complicated thing to do.

Files
New Prediction

Although I think it's unlikely and there are no current plans to do so that we know of publicly, there are dynamics that could cause such a situation to unravel, and ample time to allow for this to happen. The bar seems low for this question. Therefore, I'm climbing a tad bit higher.

Files
New Badge
probahilliby
earned a new badge:

Questions Forecasted

For forecasting in 100 questions!
New Prediction

Crowd seems too low on this one. I plotted all the current positions of the top 15 or so market caps, then compared relative probabilities using standard and median absolute deviations, and alternative inputs to account for uncertainties / margins of error. The range is 9 to 32 percent. I'm putting down the moderate estimate of 22% to start. I will reassess the future positions later down the line. Thinking I should be higher since I'm only accounting for this snapshot in time. Lots of time left on the clock means more opportunity for growth for NVIDIA.

Files
New Prediction

Affirming.

Files
New Prediction
probahilliby
made their 18th forecast (view all):
Probability
Answer
1% (0%)
Kuwait
3% (-1%)
Oman
2% (0%)
Qatar
1% (-2%)
Saudi Arabia
1% (0%)
Tunisia

Reducing for passage of time, most notably Saudi Arabia. Just don't see it appropriate given the escalation in the region.

Files
New Prediction

Aligning with DKC in her assessment, therefore riding down my perceived  overconfidence. I just don't think given the troubles Iran already faces that they will do something that would trigger such snapback sanctions.


@DKC, do you think there's room for a scenario in which Trump triggers something that causes this question to resolve YES in time? This is assuming he is re-elected US President.

Files
DKC
made a comment:

@probahilliby IMHO, I don't think Trump can do any more damage to that Iran deal than he already has. I don't think many European leaders will be willing to stick their neck out for him with his record of turning his back on them.

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/newsletters/2024-07-17/trump-tells-lovely-eu-to-brace-for-tariffs

Files
New Prediction

I'm not quite confident that I know the particular circumstances and strings that are driving this question that well. With the escalations in the Middle East, particularly between Israel, Iran and Hezbollah, I think this could embolden Iran in achieving its objectives, which includes nuclear enrichment missions.


As a rough estimate, let's assume that this question would resolve on average in 2.9 years, With a standard deviation of another three years. A normal distribution, it would assume a 20% forecast for this question with the remaining time left. (EDIT: Glad to see no forecaster is above 20% here). But given that this is a skewed distribution, I think a 4% is more appropriate, which is aligned with my previous forecast which was derived subjectively. Therefore, I am affirming my forecast of 4% for now. I am particularly monitoring what's happening in the Middle East regarding Hezbollah and Iran.

Files
DKC
made a comment:

@probahilliby Just an FYI: I found this article helpful in understanding this question better. It's a year old, but explains some of the nuance and limitations.

https://www.washingtoninstitute.org/policy-analysis/iran-deals-october-sunsets-sanctions-without-snapback

Files
Files
Tip: Mention someone by typing @username