srl

Scott Lawrence
About:
Show more

-0.000073

Relative Brier Score

14

Forecasts

4

Upvotes
Forecasting Activity
Forecasting Calendar
 

Past Week Past Month Past Year This Season All Time
Forecasts 11 11 14 14 14
Comments 1 1 1 1 1
Questions Forecasted 11 11 12 12 12
Upvotes on Comments By This User 3 3 4 4 4
 Definitions


New Prediction
srl
made their 1st forecast (view all):
Probability
Answer
Forecast Window
18%
Yes
Nov 19, 2024 to Nov 19, 2025
82%
No
Nov 19, 2024 to Nov 19, 2025

Probably dominated by death or incapacitation, which at 85 years is around 15% per year (assuming nothing is known about the individual's health, which is probably close to right for Khamenei). Everything else seems unlikely: assassination would be extremely counterproductive for Israel (and Israel has demonstrated the ability to behave rationally); fleeing the country would imply a revolution, with a per-year probability less than 5%, resignation (absent incapacitation) would require a solid succession plan which doesn't seem to be in place.

Files
New Prediction
srl
made their 1st forecast (view all):
Probability
Answer
1%
Kuwait
2%
Oman
2%
Qatar
2%
Saudi Arabia
1%
Tunisia

With only a little more than a month left, all of these should be below 10% just because the per-year probability is less than 100%. Kuwait, and Tunisia seem more hostile, SA and Oman less. Qatar's behavior is bizarre and I don't know what to think. I'll give the hostile ones a 10% per-year probability (that's the minimum anyway), SA and Oman 20%, and Qatar 15% (rounded to 20%).

Files
New Badge
srl
earned a new badge:

Questions Forecasted

For forecasting on 10 questions!
New Prediction
srl
made their 1st forecast (view all):
This forecast will expire on Dec 19, 2024
Probability
Answer
Forecast Window
2%
Yes
Nov 19, 2024 to May 19, 2025
98%
No
Nov 19, 2024 to May 19, 2025

50/50 on this happening by 2040, with most of that concentrated before 2030, so let's say 30% by 2030. That's five years, giving 3% in the next six months. My vague understanding is that the probability should be even lower for the near term because PLA doesn't have all the material it needs prepared (and I can't imagine what advantage would be gained from an isolated attack). Happy to put 2%.

Files
New Prediction
srl
made their 1st forecast (view all):
Probability
Answer
Forecast Window
15%
Yes
Nov 19, 2024 to May 19, 2025
85%
No
Nov 19, 2024 to May 19, 2025

Naive base rate calculation (assuming Poisson): six tests in the last 20 years gives an expectation of 0.15 tests per six months.

Taking presidential election timing into account doesn't increase the probability that much. Taking the same window around inauguration, the only test that qualified was February 2013. There have been four inaugurations since the first test (2009, 2013, 2017, 2021), so that gives a 25% probability, with large error bars.

Difficult to see what NK would gain from this sort of timing of a test, but also I don't think of NK's behavior as being entirely rational. Sticking with base rate.

Files
New Prediction
Why do you think you're right?

I don't see what advantage Iran would have by withdrawing. Lose some diplomatic benefits and relief from sanctions, and simultaneously lose the ability to blame the U.S.

Were Khamenei to lose power in the next 40 days, this would still be overwhelmingly unlikely. A reformist government would seek a return to compliance and an expansion of JCPOA; a hardline government would still want to remain in JCPOA.

Iran's government has shown an ability to think somewhat strategically, so the fact that this is clearly a negative for the country _and_ the government is strong evidence that it won't happen.

Add that to timing considerations.


Files
Why might you be wrong?

Files
New Prediction
srl
made their 1st forecast (view all):
Probability
Answer
Forecast Window
40%
Yes
Nov 17, 2024 to Nov 17, 2025
60%
No
Nov 17, 2024 to Nov 17, 2025

Flattening of scaling laws should tighten competition, making the outcome more random and reducing the impact of the advantages that U.S.-based companies have.

Files
New Prediction

The catalog linked in the question reveals that 15 certificates have been issued so far. Plenty of OTICs have not yet issued any certificates:

  • ritt7layers and Singapore in Asia
  • Berlin, Madrid, Paris in Europe
  • All of the NA ones
Overall, that's about half of OTICs excluding the NA ones. If I include NA ones that previously existed, then maybe 1/3rd of OTICs have issued a certificate. It seems almost certain that in the next few years, at least one NA OTIC will issue a certificate.

Another observation. About 7 certificates were issued in 2023. Then I expect 2 or 3 to be issued in the remaining 4.5 months. Each has (at best) a 1/3 chance of coming from an NA OTIC, which results in a ~50% probability of one of them being from NA. This assumes nothing's correlated which is kind of silly, but I'm not at all sure which way the correlation should go!

Files
New Prediction

The major RAN vendors are apparently Ericsson, Huawei, and Nokia, which together have about three-quarters market share. Both Nokia and Ericsson are members of the O-RAN alliance. I can't find when they joined. Ericsson has been a member at least since late last year.

ZTE is sometimes listed, along with Huawei, as a telecom company that causes security concerns for the west. ZTE is a member of the O-RAN alliance. This has been true at least since 2020. The alliance was founded in 2018.

The resolution criteria are pretty broad as well.

It seems like a 50% chance that Huawei is a member at the end of the decade, leaving something like a 10% chance that it's a member in a year. That's a sort of lower bound on this probability, and then I have to worry about the chance of a "collaboration", which must be at least as likely.

Since the crowd forecast is so low, I'll go with a lowest probability I can justify.

Files
New Prediction

Going (slightly) higher than the crowd here. Increased volatility (Israel, Trump winning) pushes probabilities away from the extremes.

Files
Files
Tip: Mention someone by typing @username